A freight invoice audit checks each carrier invoice against the load before you pay it. For a broker or 3PL, the charges have to match the agreed carrier rate on the rate confirmation, and a signed POD has to be on file. Charges that match get paid. Anything extra waits until someone approves it or disputes it.
Checking linehaul and fuel takes a minute. The time goes to the charges nobody expected, like detention or a lumper fee, because only the rep who covered the load knows whether they were agreed. A FlowRunner flow audits every invoice from your carrier invoice inbox and sends only those charges to the rep.
- 1Invoice arrivesA PDF in your carrier invoice inbox
- 2Agent reads itCarrier, load number, every charge
- 3Checked in your TMSAgainst the rate con and the POD
- 4The rep on the load decidesOnly the charges that don't match
- 5Bill createdWith who approved what
One carrier invoice, start to finish
Here is a sample invoice from Red River Transport for a van load from Chicago to Dallas. The flow read the PDF, found the load in Turvo, and pulled the agreed carrier rate. It also downloaded the rate confirmation and the POD. Linehaul and fuel match. The detention line doesn’t.
| Charge | Rate con | Invoice |
|---|---|---|
| Linehaul, Chicago, IL to Dallas, TX | $2,150.00 | $2,150.00 |
| Fuel surcharge | $412.00 | $412.00 |
| Both match the rate confirmation. A signed POD is on the load, and no earlier invoice for it is on file. | ||
| Detention, 3 hours at $50 | none | $150.00 |
| The rate confirmation has no detention on this load, and nobody has approved it yet. | ||
| Total | $2,562.00 | $2,712.00 |
The flow holds the invoice and asks Luis, the rep who covered the load, in Slack:
Slack, direct message to the rep on the load
Detention not on the rate con: Red River Transport, load 40218-77301
Invoice 20417 bills $150.00 of detention, 3 hours at $50. Linehaul and fuel match, and the POD is on file. The rest is ready to pay.
What times are on the POD at delivery?
The receiver stamped the POD in at 8:02 AM and out at 1:05 PM on Nov 7, against an 8:00 AM appointment. The rate confirmation allows 2 hours free, then $50 an hour.
Luis remembers the receiver calling about the late unload, and clicks Approve $150. The flow creates the bill in QuickBooks Online with the decision on it:
Invoice 20417, load 40218-77301. Linehaul $2,150.00 and fuel $412.00 match the rate confirmation. POD signed Nov 7. Detention $150.00 approved by Luis Ortega in Slack, Nov 11, 2:18 PM, from POD times in 8:02 AM, out 1:05 PM.
The flow also attaches the invoice to the load in Turvo and adds the approved $150 of detention to the customer’s charges, so the shipper is billed for the detention you paid. Then it moves the load to Ready for billing. Had Luis clicked Dispute, the flow would have replied in the carrier’s email thread with the reason and held the bill.
A clean invoice with a POD on file becomes a bill without anyone touching it. Every run keeps a step-by-step record of each check and each answer, so you can show a carrier or an auditor why a charge was paid.
Invoices come in through Gmail, and the load and its documents come from Turvo. The rep answers in Slack, and bills go to QuickBooks Online.
What a freight invoice audit checks
A carrier invoice audit is the freight version of a three-way match. The rate confirmation takes the place of the purchase order, and the POD takes the place of the receipt.
| Check | Compared against | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Linehaul and fuel | The agreed carrier rate | Carriers bill from their own records |
| Each accessorial | The rate confirmation and the evidence on the POD | An extra charge needs both agreement and proof |
| Proof of delivery | A signed POD on the load | Your customer invoice needs the same POD |
| Duplicate | Invoices and bills already on file for this load | Carriers resend invoices, sometimes under a new number |
| Carrier | The carrier booked on the load | The company billing you should be the one you tendered the load to |
Pre-audit, post-audit, and freight audit and payment
| Type | When it happens | Who it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-audit | Before the invoice is paid | Brokers and 3PLs paying carriers on short terms |
| Post-audit | After payment, looking back for overpayments | Anyone recovering past overcharges |
| Freight audit and payment (FAP) | An outside provider audits and pays the invoices for you | Shippers paying many carriers under contract rates |
Wikipedia defines freight audit as “examining, adjusting and verifying freight bills for accuracy” and notes that post-payment audits can recover overpayments going back years. For a broker, the pre-audit is the one that stops a wrong charge before the money leaves.
The freight invoice audit process, step by step
- Capture the invoice: carrier, invoice number, load or PRO number, and every charge line.
- Find the load and confirm the carrier on the invoice is the carrier on the load.
- Check that this invoice hasn’t been entered or paid already.
- Compare linehaul and fuel with the agreed carrier rate.
- Check each accessorial against the rate confirmation and the evidence for it.
- Confirm a signed POD is on file.
- Approve the bill, or hold it and ask the rep on the load.
- Keep the decision with the bill.
Exceptions and what the flow does
| Exception | What it looks like | What the flow does |
|---|---|---|
| Rate mismatch | Linehaul billed at $2,300 against $2,150 on the rate con | Asks the rep, with both numbers |
| Accessorial not on the rate con | $150 of detention nobody approved | Asks the rep, with the POD times and the rate con terms |
| Lumper without a receipt | A lumper fee with no receipt attached | Replies to the carrier asking for the receipt and holds the bill |
| No POD on file | The invoice arrives before the POD | Replies to the carrier asking for the POD and holds the bill |
| Duplicate | The same invoice resent “in case you missed it” | Stops it and shows the bill already entered |
| Different carrier | The invoice comes from a company other than the one booked | Holds it and asks the rep and AP before anything is paid |
Detention and the other accessorials each have their own rules and evidence, and they get a full article of their own.
Other ways to audit freight invoices
| Approach | How it works | When it fits |
|---|---|---|
| A FlowRunner flow | Reads emailed invoices, checks them in your TMS, asks the rep in Slack or by email, and creates the bill | Invoices arrive by email and you want your own rules and routing |
| Freight audit and payment provider | An outside firm audits and pays carrier invoices for you | Shippers with high volume under contract rates |
| Factoring document check | Truckstop’s Document Audit compares a load’s documents with the job details when the load is submitted for funding | Brokers already funding loads through Truckstop |
| Manual review | AP opens the rate con and the POD next to each invoice | Low volume, one person who knows every load |
Truckstop’s check covers the paperwork behind the invoice you send. A flow covers the carrier’s invoice you receive and takes any mismatch to the rep who covered the load. For the same idea applied to other invoices, see invoice validation. Brokers and 3PLs can see more on the logistics page.
How to start
Start with your ten busiest carriers. Their invoices repeat, and most of their loads come through clean.
For the first two weeks, send every extra charge to the rep, even small ones. Then set the amounts you approve without a question, carrier by carrier, from what your reps approved.
Frequently asked questions
What is a freight invoice audit?
A freight invoice audit checks a carrier's invoice against what was agreed and what happened on the load before the invoice is paid. For a broker or 3PL, that means the rate confirmation and the signed proof of delivery. Charges that match are paid, and anything else waits for someone to approve or dispute it.
What is the difference between a freight pre-audit and a post-audit?
A pre-audit checks the invoice before you pay it, so a wrong charge is never paid. A post-audit looks back at invoices already paid to find overpayments and claim them back. Brokers paying carriers on short terms get the most from the pre-audit.
What documents do you need to audit a carrier invoice?
The carrier's invoice, the rate confirmation for the load, and the signed POD. For accessorials you also need the evidence behind them, such as in and out times on the POD for detention or a receipt for a lumper charge.